Skip to main content
Presilium Private Wealth
Investing & Markets

Financial Planning Fridays #103: Market Returns After 5% Pull Backs

When the market fell sharply in early August 2024, Presilium followed its plan and rebalanced client accounts, an approach designed to add to stock exposure after meaningful declines from a prior rebalance. Drawing on Goldman Sachs data since 1980, this episode reviews how forward returns after such pullbacks have historically tended to look. Past performance does not guarantee future results; this is educational, not investment advice.

When the market fell sharply in early August 2024, Presilium followed its plan and rebalanced client accounts, an approach designed to add to stock exposure after meaningful declines from a prior rebalance. Drawing on Goldman Sachs data since 1980, this episode reviews how forward returns after such pullbacks have historically tended to look. Past performance does not guarantee future results; this is educational, not investment advice.

Key takeaways

  • Presilium rebalances and buys stock when markets fall 5% or more from the prior rebalance.
  • This rules-based approach removes emotion from buying during declines.
  • Historical data since 1980 shows positive average forward returns after pullbacks.
  • Pullbacks can be opportunities for disciplined investors rather than reasons to sell.
  • Past return patterns do not guarantee future results.

Hi Friends. On August 5, 2024 the market was down more than 8% from the last peak reached on July 16, 2024. According to our plan, we rebalanced our client accounts and purchased additional stock. We do this every time the market is down 5% or more from our previous rebalance. Let’s look together at how that strategy has worked out since 1980. This great chart from Goldman Sachs shows the forward results of the S&P 500 after a 5% downturn after 1, 3, 6, and 12 months. The axis on the right side shows the percent of time the market is positive after a 5% pullback for each time period. It is positive about 70% of the time after a month, and positive 85% of the time after 6 months. This tells me that most 5% market pullbacks are not the start of a larger decline but instead are great opportunities to add to stock at a temporarily lower price. Furthermore, the data shows that in the 6 months after a 5% decline, the median and average market return is more than 6% which would have erased the previous 5% loss in the S&P 500. And finally, both the median and average return after 12 months has been well above 10%. We have had 39 5% pullbacks in the S&P 500 since 1980. From our perspective, that means we have had 39 excellent buying opportunities for our clients, opportunities that we will continue to look for and take advantage of. Thank you and I look forward to talking with you next Friday. Be on the lookout for our next Financial Planning Fridays episode. Subscribe to our Youtube Channel so you never miss an episode. Or contact us directly; schedule your 15-minute call with us today.

Written by

Jerry Davidse

Chief Executive Officer · CFP®

Turn insight into a plan

The first conversation is 30 minutes, no preparation needed.